Showing posts with label diversity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label diversity. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Politics and Brain Development

To what degree does our political system form the way we think?

I thought about this question during a political discussion regarding the awkward marriage of party politics and the Canadian riding system, which we happened to agree suggests direct personal representational rather than ideological politics (if I can dichotomize those...). For clarification, what I mean is that the Canadian system seems to suggest an ideal in which constituents vote based on which candidate they believe will best represent their local interests nationally, rather than which local candidate represents the political ideology they subscribe to, or the "party" whose national platform I like best, or whose leader I like best. Anyway I came to ponder to what degree our very political system form our binary and ideological thinking? Is perhaps our polarized society and often vicious debates, socially, politically, and theologically, at least in part a result of the very systems we have created and live in? The American two party system and Canadian party system seem unable to capture the political nuance, which I would suggest are needed in our multicultural society and global village in which it is situated.  Do representation by population democracies, such as are more common in Europe, contribute to what, from my perspective, tend to be individuals who both hold more nuanced and tolerant positions than seem common in North America?

It is my off the cuff impression, that those who have spent more than a year in a country with a "rep by pop" democracy, in which every vote counts (in a way that is not true of our systems), generally are significantly more capable of generating multiple solutions, thinking from other perspectives, and generally holding more nuance political, social and religious convictions than those who have live exclusively in North America. In this comment I am explicitly acknowledging my own tendency toward binary thinking having lived primarily in North America in contrast to some other people I know with more international experience, and am away that I am setting up a binary in this very post between North America and Europe.

Nevertheless, if any of this is even marginally true I think it then suggests that as we talk about learning to live in tension, which is a very common conversation in my life, we MUST create social and political and perhaps economic systems that also function in tension, ideally the multifaceted tensions which represent the realities of our world. However, our elected dictatorships generally do not function at all in tension and rather either are party regimes or entirely non - functioning. To be fair Beligium's non government for nearly 6 months does not necessarily support the functionality of the other system.

Thoughts?

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

True or False?

Here is something I am pondering but also that I think society is pondering at a number of levels...

I pose these as a number of questions.

Is it better to believe/know the truth or a non truth?
This one seems simple... the truth is a pretty high value fairly universally in our context.

Is it better to believe/know the truth because of a non truth or to believe a non truth because of truth?

To state it again: Which is preferable truth base on something false or something false based on truth?

Another question along these lines would be is it better to be right or to be rational?

Ok so now we add an interpersonal dimension.

Does non truth need to be corrected?
Probably a fairly simple agreement from most people...

Who is it more important to correct: Mr. Wrong Conclusion or Mr. Wrong Premise?

To place this in a faith context: would you destroy someone's faith over a false premise?

Would you tell a lie to convince someone of the truth?

I think these are harder and more complex questions than we think.

Obviously truth and non truth are often not easy to separate or discern... However this is in part why some of these questions arise...

Our society seems to be thematically repeating the idea that society needs to believe a lie to function... That order requires a certain amount of deceit. Batman: The Dark Night in particular highlights this. But I've noticed it come up in a few other things and contexts recently... (sorry I am failing to recall specifics).

Anyway, I would love to have some dialogue about this... It is particularly the value judgement that I find fascinating...

Monday, November 7, 2011

Oh if only I were actually Insane.

I recently watched the new BBC Sherlock, and also Showcase's Californication. Without reserve I would recommend Sherlock. With serious content disclaimers (sex and drugs) I would also recommend Californication. What the shows have in common are seriously dysfunctional protagonists. However, in the midst of there dysfunction, choices seem clear and simple, even if life isn't, they find success even amidst their own disaster, and they seem content with the mixture of love and hatred with which they are surrounded.

I binge watched these shows over the weekend as I am currently attempting to stress out less, trust my own process a bit more and not allow other people's processes to place unnecessary guilt or expectations on me. So I didn't do much homework and enjoyed Netflix. Can I live with myself doing things the way I do things? Can Amy live with me doing things the way I do things? Can I live with what you think of me procrastinating and watching TV instead of finishing assignments early?

The stress and thrill of deadlines left until the last minute, there are few things more exhilarating...

I find it very easy to get stuck inside my own head of games and perceptions. My own stress and anxiety over success and also the perception of success, and also the perception of diligence and effort. I found myself wondering this weekend if perhaps stressing out regarding papers and assignments before they are due when others have started and I have not is perhaps ineffective. I sometimes try and goad myself into starting or working by stressing and guilting myself into it. However, what if I trusted that I can effectively evaluate the natural stress of the situation and will start the assignment with enough time to finish, even if just barely. And that perhaps more effective preparation is rest and relaxation of all kinds (mental, emotional, physical) so that when my brain finally clicks into the clarity of last minute deadline magic I have the energy to make the magic happen.

Is our reverence of the dysfunctional genius, creating more dysfunction as we are unable to separate madness and genius and find ourselves celebrating and fascinated by both, leading us down a path of imitation... I find myself amusingly jealous with what I occasionally perceive as the simplicity of thought and life that mental illness can afford people. We often make very large allowances for those with diagnosed dysfunction. And the individual may or may not be aware or care about social nuance or the perception of others. I often find both my ability and compulsion to "fake" my self or my thoughts for the sake of perceptions and social fluidity annoying. Sometimes I wish I was an assh*le. If you already think that I am, I guess you caught me on a good day. Its not that I want to descend into uncensored brashness or hedonism, it is that I desire my altruism to be authentic and I would like to interact with people with greater confidence and freedom.

If you want to know how I could recommend Californication ask me. Also if you have CYOA requests let us know we are running low. Maybe we could start on some Christmas passages... What are your favourites?

Monday, October 17, 2011

#OccupyVancouver - On the ground

Ok so I have attended two general assemblies, went on the march on Saturday and just hung out a bit. On the first day there was 3-5000 people who showed up. Which was both amazing and I think overwhelming. We had great weather and a great march and the village was established. People are learning on the ground why democracy is slow and not everyone is excited. But there was another significant turnout on Sunday as the group continues to work to nail down a consensus process. Part of this process involved breakout groups which allow crowd discussion and ideas to happen and move to the mic. This was the best part of the day. People worked hard at actually communicating - speaking and listening - it was respectful, empowering and effective. There was also an interesting win for free speech when a participant was able to disagree with the movement's non violent position from the microphone reasonably articulately.

I had the opportunity to talk about #OccupyVancouver last night to a friend and failed miserably to communicate the fascinating and inspiring and moral nature of this movement. While in some respects so far it has been a protester convention, everyone with their own pet project and priorities, protesting is not the primary focus of what the group is trying to do. #OccupyVancouver is literally recreating society in microcosm, from scratch. While they are united in discontent, the movement is incredibly proactive. I say movement because occupy camps now exist in 900+ cities globally. By looking at the created microcosm societies in New York and Vancouver (the only two I have significant information on) it is easy to see what they/we want.

Consensus participatory direct democracy is the format in which the community thinks through and decides things. What does this say? I believe it is a critique of partisan politics and Canadian elected dictatorships, which is effectively what a majority government is. Furthermore, it is the demand for greater direct access, control or voice in our communities and countries. I think there is a sense that the ballot once every few years has become an ineffective way of voicing political opinions or communal desires. I think that the successful overturning of the HST is a clear indication that citizens want clear accurate information and a voice and will not have things foisted on them any longer. Regardless of your opinion on the HST, the results demonstrate the power of direct democracy, people's willingness to participate and their distrust of government. Furthermore, the consensus model emphasizes the desire for unity and the good of everyone AND a belief that this is possible. It fairly questions the idea a 51% majority in the house of commons should have the right to make decisions for everyone. Interestingly, the other places where consensus models of governance and decision making exist are the Orthodox Church, a number of First Nations tribes and the Quakers (Please add more that you know of in the comments). There is the political question at stake: Do we just want stuff to happen or do we want the right stuff to happen? And also how do we know or find out what the right stuff is? I think the financial, and environmental crisis highlight the increased perception that taking the time to really make good decisions that really represent everyone and the good of the planet are what is needed, rather than efficient political structures that exempt personal voice or responsibility, encourage passivity and apathy and are influenced by corporate voices more than community voices. Furthermore, the democratic ideals are founded on the belief that together we can make better decisions - if you think that the majority of people are stupid and shouldn't have a voice then go live in China because that's how they run things over there.

To the end of creating a community that is safe and inclusive and takes care of everyone, #OccupyVancouver provides free food - everyone is fed, everyone is kept warm, everyone has a voice, everyone participates. They claim they are the 99% and they offer a vision of what society could look like if the 99% re-evaluated their goals of wealth and luxury, continually chasing that 1%. #OccupyVancouver, minus some prayers and songs, looks more like the Acts 2 church than any church I know of...

The #Occupy movement has successfully imagined the possibility of imagining a better society with economic and social justice. They are actively working to not just offer ideas and suggestions, which there are lots of, but to also actually create it on the ground. This is exciting and inspiring I encourage you to find out more and get involved.