Showing posts with label heresy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label heresy. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

A Disconcerting Trend


I sit here with an uncomfortable feeling in my gut. It is a feeling that has been around for a long time now. Sometimes the feeling seems to have teeth that gnaw at me, other times it lays dormant, maybe for a week, maybe a few months; whatever the case it continues to rear its ugly head.

I have been unsure of whether or not to blog this, but here I go (so maybe it is time?).

The disconcerting trend that makes me anxious is a growing idolatry of certainty within churches, and pejorative name calling by those within the church. These two things seem to be on the rise, slowly but surely, they march on to dominate and oppress others who do not fit the mould. I am experiencing and witnessing this trend within Abbotsford, as well as in the greater area of the lower mainland. The trend has been growing recently (or maybe I am simply continuing to become more aware of it).

I have two examples of the pejorative verbatim tossed around in churches, in Bible College, and even in conversations between friends. These two examples point toward an underlying sentiment, which I believe is one factor in the rise of idolizing certainty. The first example comes from far away (better to attack what is at a distance before striking too near the heart). Three years ago in Israel, while learning about the physical and geographical settings of the Bible, I was confronted by “maximalist” and “minimalist”. These terms regarded the “group” a certain scholar or idea fit. For example, are these group of rocks store houses or stables? One position was maximalist, one was minimalist. The “maximalists” held to a certain position, usually that which “agreed” with the Bible, and the “minimalist” position would conclude differently. Both positions looked at the same evidence, and considered the Bible, and came to different conclusions (it is my opinion that both groups we guilty of cooking the evidence at times). The problem that arises, the thing that rubs me the wrong way, is that once the groupings were established the way the terms were used became harmful. This occurred in Israel, by the end of the trip if you thought a “minimalist” position might be right there was a stigma sent in your direction. You obviously had weak faith, you did not believe the Bible (or at least you do not take it seriously), you may not be saved, you were sub par, and you might even be a “liberal”! The classification of “minimalist” became a pejorative.

The second example is quickly growing in the vernacular of the circles I skirt. It is defence of one’s ideas by entrenching one’s self based on having a “high view of scripture”. This subsequently implies, or has even be explicitly stated, that the one with whom he or she disagrees has a “low view of scripture”. It has been my experience, and some of those around me, that this is incredibly hurtful, often said without proper thought or care for the other, and can be invested with a derogatory tone.

Here are some thoughts/responses to this pejorative usage: A) simply because you land in one place and someone else disagrees does not mean he or she has a “low view of scripture”, there have been disagreements for as long as religion has existed (so get off your “high” horse). B) One’s worldview often dictates one’s conclusions more than external evidence. Scripture might not even be the actual argument or disagreement; rather there may be a clash of worldview. So, if one dogmatically claims the “high view of scripture” without plenty of self-critique and humility, he or she exudes arrogance, pride, self-righteousness, and ignorance. C) Just because the historical/grammatical method of exegesis and interpretation lead to one answer it does not mean it is the “correct” answer or interpretation. It was not simply arrived at because of one’s “high view of scripture”. There are a plethora of interpretive methods, and a vast array of interpretations within each method, so honestly consider some alternative possibilities. D) Someone might hold such a “high view of scripture” that they have spent their entire life studying, reading, investing resources, listening to others, caring for others, and re-thinking faith. This person may eventually come to a new or different conclusion because of their “high view of scripture”, so to then label this new view as having it base in a “low view of scripture” is to slander the other.

Whew, it feels nice to get that off my internet chest. Which leads us to the new atheists (fundamentalists), atheists, as those who rely on the idolatry of certainty. Positions arrived at by the underlying disposition that manifests itself in pejorative language.

Rolling beneath these trends of pejorative vernacular is a more disconcerting movement. It is a movement of correctness. Not political correctness or the certainty that 2+2=4 within the agreed upon public consciousness (“where as 2+2=5”, as my dad would say, “in very high values of 2”). No, “correctness” in the manner of “I am right” (implying all others to be wrong). This “correctness” lies in the outflow of certainty. The need for certainty, or rather the religious crutch of certainty, which will lead to a behaviour of “correctness”. This may manifest itself is such statements as “I know what I know”, or “ask questions, find answers”, or “don’t read that! He or she is a heretic”, or “maybe it is more…but it is certainly not less”. It is in such statements that idols are erected. Idols that stand in the place of something or more often then not someone. The idol of certainty limits our ability to interact with each other as well as God. For if we are certain of God or another, we implicitly demote him or her or God from the position of a free agent or person to the realm of object, where actions are known and can be calculated. Such object interactions are bound to fail, people continue to surprise, and God continues to defy boxes.

Certainty, and the idolization of it, manifests itself in both Atheism and Fundamentalism (given there are exceptions, I know some great doubting Atheists, as well as a few questioning fundamentalists). Certainty had it heyday with modernism. “I think therefore I am”, “only that which can be proven through the scientific method can be known”, “the Bible says…”, etc. This time gave rise to atheism as it is commonly understood as well as religious fundamentalism. These two groups are not very far apart in their mode of thought, rather they reflect each other, not as estranged cousins but more like . Both appear to lack an epistemological humility, and a disposition towards the knower’s fallibility.

I’ll leave it at that, knowing I am probably wrong ;)

Monday, February 20, 2012

Evolution...

As we listened to lecture, by Dr. Paul Teel, on evolution last week, a friend leaned over and whispered to me, "I'm going to ask, 'If evolution is true how come there are still monkeys?'" I suggested he casually scratch his armpits while he asked. He responded, "Yeah or shit in my hand then throw it at the lecturer..."

Evolution is a hot button topic for Christians particularly evangelicals so it seems fitting that we address it. Most of us are familiar with people the passionate Young Earth Creationist position: the earth is 5-10 000 years old Genesis 1-11 is concrete historical reality, evolution is lie perpetuated by sinful unbelieving scientists, if Genesis isn't "true" than why should we believe in Jesus...

I have sympathy for this position. I have held it within the past 10 years. And while I no longer hold this position and in fact, I would use words like "false teaching" to describe it. I want to affirm that these are people with good intentions passionate about their faith and scripture. 

Another group can be loosely described as the "It doesn't matter" group... This I think is approximately where my parents stand and where I was prior to my couple of years of fundamentalism. This group generally argues that creation "perspectives" are a non "salvation" issue and therefore not worthy of argument or broken relationship. The focus on "salvation" issues highlights our "salvation" priority that I pointed out and questioned in What is the Gospel? last week. 

The third position I present is Evolutionary Creationists. This is the position of Dr. Paul Teel. This would be how I categorize myself. This is is the position that recently got a Regent professor uninvited from preaching at the church he pastored for 10 years...! This position takes science, the Bible and theology very seriously. It affirms variation in breeding, leading to advantageous mutations which are paid off in increased reproduction (natural selection), and that this process is continuous and ongoing... This position affirms the authority of the Bible and argues that Gen. 1-11 are not concrete history (a position already held by Augustine) but mythic theological presentation and reflection. Thus this position considers creation to by a dynamic community of beings upheld through space and time by the Triune God. Evolution does not interpret itself and does not require one to be an atheist. 

Ok so these are three positions. There are a few more, which are nuances of these, but I am not going to address them.

I want to affirm that all truth is God's truth. I want to affirm science and scientist's pursuit of the truth and embrace with them their discoveries of the good creation God has created. I want to be aware of both the limits of science to speak to metaphysics and that the foundations of science rest on Christian theology. I want to be able to talk about faith and science without fear...

I have some friends who no longer identify as Christians. These same people are passionate seekers of truth and believe that evolutionary theory is true. While, like with everything, beliefs and conversions, either to or away from faith are complex, I wonder to myself would it have been as easy to walk away from a church deeply engaged with positive dialogue with science? Does the common Bible vs. Science binary, create a very strong sense that if one accepts science, one must reject faith? I think this perception is very common and unfortunately is unwittingly perpetuated by those who say, "it doesn't matter..." This group is very difficult to determine the size of because of their effective silence within the conversation. Usually this means that the YEC position gets the megaphone and the floor... From my perspective this is a problem on a number of levels. 1) it perpetuates poor literalististic/"first glance" Biblical hermeneutics and exegesis 2) Christian youth are either prepared by the church to be dogmatic fundamentalists or not prepared at all, and therefore liable to reject the church when they discover the church has largely rejected/not engaged "reality"... 3) Those outside the church most engaged in truth seeking are, not inaccurately, likely to be dismissive of a community that out of ignorance and misguided loyalty has rejected observed reality 4) Scientists inside the church are largely ostracised...

Therefore, the way we handle this issue in a very real way has consequences both in keeping and gaining community members... Of course taking a positive position towards evolution is liable to get you declared a heretic by someone, people might leave your church, if you are a pastor you might get fired, or you may be "uninvited" to speak at a church you previously pastored... I expect that someone will declare this post "heretical"... Given that Darwin was a Christian, and many early evangelicals such as Benjamin Warfield and Augustus Hopkins Strong were strong supporters of evolutionary theory... I think it is sad that we have subsequently allowed this issue to be divided and polarized in such an unfortunate way. So speak up next time it comes up and say, "I believe in evolution and I believe in God and I believe in the authority of the Bible."

If you are interested in further exploring the Evolutionary Creation position (for you doubters, yes this is actual science, I promise) check out:

BioLogos - founded by Dr. Francis Collins (head of the Human Genome Project)

The best would be if churches started having legitimate scientific symposiums with these guys...

Ok. My final comment is my dream of both Biologos and AnswersinGenesis being at Missionsfest Vancouver next year and engaging in a dance battle right in the middle of all the booths to some old school Hokus Pick or maybe DC Talk... 

Friday, February 17, 2012

Public Service Announcement

For whom it may concern we have, with a twinkle in our eye, placed the boxes "Brilliant" "Interesting" and "Heretical" below each post as a quick way of giving us feed back regarding your reaction to what we write.

It may seem given their order that they effectively mean: "Agree" "Neutral" and "Disagree". This however is not the case.

It is perfectly conceivable to acknowledge something as "brilliant" even while "disagreeing... it is perfectly conceivable that you find something that you agree, disagree or aren't sure about "interesting"... In fact I often find the stuff I disagree with far more interesting than stuff I agree with... "Interesting" in particular suggests appreciation regarding presentation and topic...

"Heretical" or as I like to call it the: "I'm an asshole box."  There are two possibilities I consider when we receive a check in the heretical box 1) that you have great sense of humour and feel positively about our post but are affirming that there are assholes that would call us heretics and clicking the box because its hilarious or 2) you are an asshole.

The word "Heretic" is a loaded term that gets thrown around way to much in current theological discussion, particularly at the average level, where study is shallow, nuance is minimal, emotions are excited and actual relationships are at stake.

Because of the baggage of, most notably, the Inquisition the charge of heresy is significantly greater than mere disagreement which is potentially amicable enough. No the charge of heresy has the distinct connotation that a position and therefore a person has stepped so far outside what another person considers acceptable that they are minutes away from tweeting "good bye" to their ex-friend/colleague and newly pronounced heretic. The terms excommunication and damnation are certainly the implied potential or imminent consequences for heretics, who enjoy the sixth circle of hell in Dante's inferno.

Unless you are Catholic or Orthodox you have no way determining orthodoxy with any communal authority so declaring us heretical is either hilarious or mean or both... If you are Catholic or Orthodox then we were officially heretical according to your community before whatever it is we posted that you didn't like so now you are just being mean and superfluous.

Heresy, Heretic and Heretical are conversation and relationship ending words that should either be used either with hilarity in safe relationship (with other safety words like "button") or used very very sparsely, with humility and the utter seriousness. We don't know who you are when you click "Heretical" but be aware it brings an equal amount of judgement on you as you have brought on us. If you click it, we know we are doing our jobs well. Because if we are not deemed heretical every so often clearly we have become irrelevent toaters of the status quo, and our Jesus really messed that up so we are following the greats in rattling the pot and encouraging thought and interaction with ideas. We want people to feel free to click that box, if they would deem something heretical. Of course, we expect you to also comment if you are laying such a charge... this way, together, we can redeem its current tendency to end conversations.
Now as you look at the boxes below remember this is not a simple agree or disagree system. If you want to agree or disagree make a comment... These boxes are more like a "high five" "a thoughtful nod" and "kick to the nuts/punch in the boob/crucification" and we will interpret it as such and pray for your redemption. "Funny" is of course self explanatory and is the appropriate box to tick for this post.